I love this!!! its beautiul, sad, and clipped very well together with the song! 1ST! hehe *goes and watches it again

i love the video its doesnt have a whole lot going on very simple and beautiful. i love this song you can really feel the emotion behinde it. My fav from the soundtrack

I love it! The song is amazing and the way they added in the clips from New Moon was great, too. There wasn’t too much, but there wasn’t too little either. It’s perfect! And the set location fits wonderfully with the setting of the Twilight books!
Only 17 days left!!!

This is one of my favourite songs on the soundtrack, but I didn’t like the vid. She looks so tired, although she is a very beautifull woman. I think the makeup was all wrong on her too.. But the song is awsome! I agree with you guys, it really fits the mood and it’s just very butifull! Wish they had done a better job on the vid.

@ Celly i think that that was the point she feeling what bella felt the emotion behide it so she shouldnt look happy she should look tired and a little out of it

Wow I love the video. It was great. I love that song too. One of the best on the soundtrack.

i love it! great vid

beautiful! Great done! Love it!

I’m gonna agree with all the people behind the entries above me, one of my favorites on the soundtrack. Beautiful! <3

yeh agreed, this one was probably my favourite on the soundtrack. i just think that it sums up the entire feeling of new moon in 3 minutes. love it

Definitely my favorite song on the sound track. I really hope it plays in the drowning scene, but the video makes it look like it might play during the break up scene.

This is one of my favorite songs on the soundtrack!!! The video was so pretty! This song just reminds me of Bella and what she goes through in New Moon. It fits perfectly and really gives you emotion and helps you see/feel what Bella’s feeling.

SHERIE - I agree with you about how she looks. She’s not suppose to look happy. She’s trying to convey the emotion of the song physically and in her expressions. I think it would look weird if she was happy singing about heartbreak! Lol.

this video is Beautiful! i love the scenerey and the song. its wonderfull:)

I love this song.

The location is beautiful.

They used some of the Twilight clips, yay!

I wonder if her bangs bother her …

It’s like she’s reminiscing …

This almost makes me want to cry. It’s beautiful. The song. It’s perfect for New Moon.

So - I’ve been a lurker forever and just wanted to say THANK YOU! HGE is so good at presenting the stuff I like to see. Not too much gossip, but lots of relevant stuff.

Thanks ladies!

Oh - and the video has that hauntingly beautiful aspect. And I love that they used SM’s (Stephenie Meyer’s) concept of Bella being a sattelite whose planet is gone. Very cool!

This song is definitely one of my top 3 songs off the NM soundtrack. Such a pretty, lyrical song. Really good video, portrays New Moon better. I think this should’ve been the film’s single instead of DCFC’s song.

she dresses like a lady gaga poser kinda. but thats not the point. point is, its a great and amazing song. I love it.

wow I have yet to buy my soundtrack (I’m sorry don’t hurt me!) but this song is BEAUTIFUL i love it!

Hmm…the video implies it is a song more centered around Bella’s feelings, which I can understand. Especially with the reference that StarlitViolet noted in their comment.

But, to me it is a song more from Jacob’s POV. From the first listen, especially after the line…”What a pity, what a sham. What’s the matter with your man?” And just as a whole, I feel it’s more a Jacob/Bella song.

Just my thoughts. But, I do enjoy the video, and the song is beautiful!